Skip to main content

This site is for educational purposes only. Nothing here constitutes financial advice.

Topic 92 of 189

GameFi Tokenomics Failures

Why Axie Infinity, StepN, and other play-to-earn games saw token economies collapse, the structural reasons P2E hasn't scaled to traditional gaming success, and what survived.

Beginner
8 min readUpdated July 2026Block Clarity Hub Editorial Team

The basics

The P2E Promise and Reality

Play-to-earn (P2E) crypto games promised users could earn meaningful income by playing. Axie Infinity famously enabled Philippines workers to earn higher income from playing Axie than from local wages in 2021. StepN paid users for walking. Many others followed. The structural promise: gameplay generates token value; players capture that value. The reality: most P2E token economies collapsed within months as the structural problems emerged.

Why They Failed Structurally

The fundamental issue: P2E games typically had two tokens — a 'utility' token earned through gameplay, and a 'governance' token. New player onboarding required existing players to sell utility tokens to new users. As game growth slowed, utility token supply outpaced demand. Token prices collapsed. Yields dropped. Existing players quit. The Ponzi-shape was structural, not implementation-specific. Multiple P2E games followed identical trajectories.

Axie's Trajectory

Axie Infinity peaked in late 2021. Users in Philippines, Vietnam, and elsewhere earned $300-1000+ monthly playing Axie. The model required new players continuously buying Axies (the NFT characters) from existing players. As crypto prices fell in 2022 and new player growth slowed, Axie prices and earnings collapsed. By 2023, many former players were earning a fraction of peak. The game itself continues operating but in a much smaller economic form. Axie's collapse became the canonical P2E failure story.

  • P2E promised players could earn meaningful income from gameplay
  • Most P2E games used dual-token economies with structural Ponzi shape
  • Axie peaked late 2021; collapsed through 2022
  • Multiple followers (StepN, Sweatcoin, others) followed similar trajectories

Key Takeaways

  • P2E promise was real and brief; structural collapse was predictable
  • Dual-token economies required perpetual new player growth
  • Axie is the canonical P2E failure case study
  • Most P2E followers experienced similar collapses

Going deeper

The Dual-Token Problem

Most P2E games used dual-token economies. Utility token: earned through gameplay, spent on game items, sold to fiat for earnings. Governance token: 'governance' rights, sometimes burned for utility token bonuses. The structural issue: utility tokens accumulated faster than they were burned. New players bought utility tokens from existing players to enter the game. As new player growth slowed, the buy side dried up; the sell side (existing players cashing earnings) continued. Token prices crashed inevitably.

StepN's Specific Story

StepN paid users GST tokens for walking, validated by GPS data. Required users to buy NFT sneakers (priced in SOL). At peak in mid-2022, users earned hundreds of dollars monthly. The model required new walkers continuously buying sneakers from existing users. When growth stalled, sneaker prices and GST earnings collapsed. The collapse was rapid; from peak, GST dropped 99%+ within months. Some users earned substantially during peak; most who joined late lost. StepN is now a much smaller operation than peak.

What Survived

Some elements of P2E survived. Sky Mavis (Axie's parent) launched Ronin chain (covered in case studies). Yuga Labs' games continue with NFT-based gameplay but reduced P2E mechanics. Pixels, Big Time, and other newer games use less aggressive token economies. The 'play-to-own' framing (users own game assets) survived; the 'play-to-earn' (users earn substantial passive income) didn't. Modern crypto gaming generally avoids the dual-token structural Ponzi shapes.

Web2 Games' Counter-Examples

Traditional Web2 games (Fortnite, Roblox, League of Legends) have economies that work — players spend money for cosmetics and progression, developers earn revenue, the game sustains. They don't promise 'you'll earn income.' Most P2E games inverted this — claimed users would earn rather than spend, which structurally required someone else to be paying. The cohort that 'earned' in P2E was earning from the cohort that 'spent.' Sustainable game economies are mostly spend-based; earn-based requires a Ponzi shape.

Key Takeaways

  • Dual-token economies created structural Ponzi shape requiring perpetual growth
  • StepN trajectory closely matched Axie's: peak → 99%+ collapse
  • Play-to-own (asset ownership) survived; play-to-earn (passive income) didn't
  • Modern crypto gaming generally uses less aggressive token economies

Under the hood

Why Traditional Games Economics Differ

Traditional gaming economies have several structural features P2E lacked. Asymmetric spending: most players spend small amounts; small whale cohort spends large. Consumable + cosmetic balance: items have value but don't promise income. No earning promise: players accept they're paying for entertainment. Fun-first design: games optimised for fun, not earning. Player population is endgame: large player bases sustain economies without needing perpetual growth. P2E inverted most of these and inherited Ponzi-shape collapse risk.

The Sustainable Crypto Gaming Path

Several principles for sustainable crypto gaming. Fun first: game must be entertaining without economic considerations. Asset ownership without earning promise: players own assets but aren't told they'll earn. Spending model: most players spend small amounts on cosmetics/progression. Earning is rare and bounded: top players might earn but not as primary game design. Sustainable through volume, not growth: large player base sustains without requiring perpetual recruitment. Few production games have nailed this balance; many are still trying.

Yield Guilds and Scholarship

An ecosystem emerged around P2E: yield guilds (YGG, Merit Circle, others) bought NFTs and let 'scholars' play them, splitting earnings. This created secondary economic structures around P2E games. The guilds peaked alongside Axie and similarly collapsed. Some pivoted to new business models (gaming venture investing, infrastructure); the original scholarship model is largely gone. The guild model is a useful study in how DeFi-style structures can attach to game economies.

The Counterargument

Some argue P2E's failure mode wasn't structural but specific — the games were bad, growth was unsustainable, but the principle (token economies in games) is sound. Newer projects (Sky Mavis's Ronin, Wild Forest, others) are trying again with different mechanics. The category isn't dead; whether it produces sustainable economics this cycle is genuinely uncertain. The empirical track record argues caution; the theoretical possibility space remains open.

Evaluating New P2E Projects

When new P2E projects emerge with high yields and rapid growth, the prior is they'll follow Axie's trajectory. Specific design features may delay collapse (single-token economies, capped emissions, burn mechanisms) but the underlying dynamics often persist. Engage with new P2E claims skeptically; the failure modes haven't fundamentally changed even as specific implementations evolved.

Key Takeaways

  • Traditional gaming economics differ structurally from P2E (asymmetric spending, fun-first, no earning promise)
  • Sustainable crypto gaming likely requires the spend-based model with optional earning
  • Yield guild ecosystem peaked and collapsed alongside P2E
  • Category isn't definitively dead; structural failure modes persist in new attempts
  • Empirical track record argues caution with new P2E launches

Related Content

Vote-Escrowed Tokenomics (ve)

How Curve's veCRV model pioneered lock-and-earn governance with vote weighting, why ve has been so widely copied (Convex, Velodrome, others), and the gauge wars it enabled.

Bonding Curves

How bonding curves automate token pricing without orderbooks, the math behind linear/exponential/sigmoid curves, and the pump.fun-style use cases driving memecoin distribution.

OHM-Style Forks and Protocol-Owned Liquidity

How OlympusDAO popularised the (3,3) game theory and protocol-owned liquidity, why the forks all collapsed, and what survived from the experiment.

Gauge Wars (Curve and Beyond)

How Curve's veCRV gauge voting created the original 'Curve Wars,' the bribery markets that emerged, and how the pattern spread to Balancer, Velodrome, and Aerodrome.

DAO Treasury Management

How major DAOs (Uniswap, MakerDAO, Optimism, Arbitrum) manage multi-billion-dollar treasuries, the conflicts between treasury preservation and value creation, and the patterns emerging in DAO finance.

The Four-Year Crypto Cycle

The empirical history of Bitcoin's roughly four-year boom-bust cycles, the halving-driven structural explanation, and the debate about whether the cycle pattern persists in the institutional era.

Halving Market Behaviour

How Bitcoin price has actually behaved around halvings (2012, 2016, 2020, 2024), the structural reasons behind the patterns, and what is known about the 2028 halving.

Monero Privacy — Deep Dive

How Monero's ring signatures, stealth addresses, and Bulletproof range proofs combine to provide default-on privacy for every transaction, and the regulatory pressures the project faces.

References & further reading